Blog · Spotting fake reviews
The FTC Banned Fake Reviews — Here's Why You Still Need to Check
The FTC's rule outlawed fake reviews with steep penalties, but enforcement can't reach every overseas seller — so the checking is still on you.
In August 2024, the FTC finalized its Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, and it took effect on 21 October 2024. It's a real, enforceable rule with real teeth. And yet fake reviews are still all over your favorite stores. If you're wondering how both things can be true, here's the honest answer.
What the rule actually bans
The rule targets the practices that have been polluting review sections for years. It prohibits fake and AI-generated reviews, buying or selling reviews, and undisclosed insider reviews where someone connected to the company poses as a neutral customer. The penalties are significant — civil fines can reach roughly $51,744 per violation. On paper, this is one of the strongest actions ever taken against review fraud.
Why fake reviews didn't disappear
A rule only works where it can be enforced, and that's the gap. A U.S. regulator has limited reach over sellers operating through overseas marketplaces, where much of the manipulation happens. Even domestically, the FTC can't audit millions of listings in real time — it acts on cases, not on every product page. So fake reviews persist, especially on international platforms the FTC struggles to police. The law raised the cost of cheating; it didn't make cheating impossible.
The checking is still on you
Until enforcement catches up, your best protection is the same set of manual habits that worked before the rule existed:
- Read the text under the score. A five-star rating on lukewarm words is a mismatch worth distrusting.
- Look for template phrasing. The same generic lines repeated across "different" reviewers suggest the reviews weren't written independently.
- Check timing. A burst of glowing reviews posted in a tight window can signal a planted campaign.
- Find duplicates. Identical review text under multiple names is a clear red flag.
- Notice incentive language. References to free products, discounts, or being asked to review point to incentivized feedback.
Automate the check
Doing that on every listing is a lot to ask. ReviewVigil does it for you. It's a free Chrome extension — open any product page, click once, and an AI analyzes the visible reviews for exactly the manipulation the FTC rule targets: template phrasing across reviewers, suspicious posting bursts, duplicated reviews, five-star ratings on lukewarm text, and incentivized-review language.
You get a letter grade from A to F, an estimated TRUE rating once the suspicious reviews are discounted, the percentage of reviews that look manipulated, and the specific signals it flagged. It works on any store that shows reviews — Amazon, eBay, Etsy, AliExpress, Temu, Shein, TikTok Shop — with no ads and no affiliate links. As the sustainable successor to Fakespot, which Mozilla shut down on 1 July 2025, it's built to stick around. Install ReviewVigil from the Chrome Web Store for five free checks a day.
The rule helps — you still have to look
The FTC's ban is a genuine step forward, and it gives regulators a tool they didn't have before. But a rule you can't enforce everywhere isn't a guarantee at the point of purchase. Treat the ban as backup, not a substitute for your own judgment. Read critically, trust the specific complaints, and run a quick check before you buy — because for now, the last line of defense is still you.
Check any product's reviews in one click
ReviewVigil grades the reviews on any store page and estimates the true rating. Free Chrome extension.
Add to Chrome — free Learn moreQuestions, answered
When did the FTC fake-review rule take effect?
The FTC finalized the rule in August 2024, and it took effect on 21 October 2024, banning fake, AI-generated, bought, and undisclosed insider reviews.
If fake reviews are illegal, why do they still exist?
Enforcement is limited, especially for sellers on overseas marketplaces the FTC struggles to police, so manipulated reviews persist despite the rule.
How can I check a listing myself?
Read the text behind the stars, watch for repeated phrasing and posting bursts, and use a tool like ReviewVigil to get a letter grade and estimated true rating in one click.
Keep reading
Are AliExpress Reviews Real? How to Tell
AliExpress reviews sit somewhere between useful and worthless — here is how to tell which ones to trust.
Is Temu Legit? How to Check Temu Reviews Before You Buy (2026)
Temu is a legitimate store — the risk lives in its reviews, not its legality, so here's how to read them properly.